Selling an inherited home in New York City follows the court's timeline, not the market's. An executor cannot sell until the Surrogate's Court issues letters, and estate tax returns are due nine months after death. Plan for a process measured in months, with carrying costs, building rules, and tax deadlines running the whole time.
This guide from Sean Brewer and Elina Brewer of The Brewer Team at Compass walks executors and heirs through each stage of an estate sale in Downtown Manhattan and Brooklyn: who has the authority to sell, what the court requires, how the stepped-up basis changes the tax math, what co-op and condo boards expect, and what it costs to close.
Who has the legal authority to sell an inherited property in NYC?
Only a fiduciary appointed by the Surrogate's Court. If the deceased left a will, the court admits it to probate and appoints the named executor, who receives letters testamentary. If there is no will, a family member or other eligible person petitions to become administrator and receives letters of administration.
Being named in the will is not enough on its own. Before the court's appointment, the named executor has no power to sell estate real estate. Once appointed, an executor can generally sell without every beneficiary's consent, as long as the will does not prohibit the sale. If the letters themselves restrict a sale, the executor must give notice and ask the court to approve the contract. Read the letters closely before listing.
The fiduciary also owes duties to the beneficiaries. A sale below fair market value, especially to the executor or someone close to them, can be treated as a breach of fiduciary duty, and in at least one reported case, a court ordered the executor to restore the loss to the estate.
How does probate work in Manhattan and Brooklyn?
The petition is filed in the Surrogate's Court of the county where the deceased lived: New York County for Manhattan, Kings County for Brooklyn. The executor files the original will, not a copy, along with a certified death certificate and the probate petition.
Every distributee, meaning each heir who would inherit if there were no will, must be named in the petition and served with a citation. Each can sign a waiver consenting to the executor's appointment or appear in court to object. Beneficiaries named in the will must also be notified. Filing fees are based on the value of the estate.
The court does not publish a standard timeline. An uncontested estate where every distributee signs a waiver avoids the delay of serving citations and hearing objections. Industry sources describe estate administration as taking months, and in some cases years, and note that an administrator's appointment, when there is no will, can itself take months.
What does an inherited NYC home cost to carry during probate?
The bills do not stop. Co-op maintenance obligations continue after a shareholder's death, and condo common charges, real estate taxes, utilities, and any mortgage payments continue as well. For a co-op, property taxes are built into the monthly maintenance.
That is why liquidity matters early. The executor needs access to estate funds to keep every account current while the court process runs. Missed maintenance or mortgage payments can lead to default, and in a worst case, a foreclosure sale where the lender or co-op sets the terms.
Two practical items belong on the first-week list. Call the homeowners or co-op insurance carrier, notify it of the death, and ask whether the policy restricts coverage if the home sits empty. Then secure the property: change access where appropriate, document the contents, and keep a log of every expense the estate pays.
How does the stepped-up basis affect capital gains on an inherited home?
Under federal tax rules, the basis of inherited property is generally its fair market value on the date of death, or on the alternate valuation date if the estate's personal representative elects it. The original purchase price no longer sets the gain.
Here is the math. Say a Park Slope townhouse was bought decades ago for $600,000 and was worth $4,000,000 on the date of death. If the estate sells for $4,100,000, the taxable gain is measured from $4,000,000, not $600,000. That is $100,000 before selling costs, instead of $3,500,000.
The step-up is also why a date-of-death appraisal matters. A qualified appraisal documents the basis, supports the estate tax return, and gives the executor a defensible number if a beneficiary questions the sale price later.
When does estate tax come into play in New York?
Two tax systems apply, with very different thresholds. For deaths in 2026, the federal estate tax exemption is $15,000,000 per person. New York's basic exclusion amount is $7,350,000.
New York's rule has a cliff. If the taxable estate exceeds the exclusion by more than 5 percent, the exclusion is lost and the entire estate is taxed, not just the amount above the threshold. In 2026, that cliff begins above $7,717,500, which is $7,350,000 multiplied by 1.05. For a Manhattan or Brooklyn owner with a $4,000,000 home, retirement accounts, and investments, the combined estate can cross that line faster than the family expects.
When an estate must file, both returns are due nine months after the date of death. The New York return is Form ET-706, and the federal return is Form 706. Each allows a six-month extension to file, but an extension to file does not extend the time to pay. If the house is the estate's main asset, the sale schedule may need to line up with that payment date. Review the estate's numbers with an estate attorney and CPA.
What do co-op and condo boards require when an estate sells?
In a co-op, the estate owns shares and a proprietary lease, not real property. Most proprietary leases allow a transfer to a surviving spouse without board consent. Other beneficiaries who want to keep the apartment generally go through the full board application, and a rejection usually leaves selling as the path forward.
Many proprietary leases also require the apartment to be transferred or sold within a set period after the shareholder's death, and the board can enforce that deadline even while probate is still running. Pull the proprietary lease and house rules early and confirm the deadline in writing with the managing agent. Many co-ops also charge a flip tax, often cited at around 2 percent of the sale price and typically paid by the seller.
Condos follow the probate process for real property, and the executor signs a new deed at closing. A condo sale still involves a buyer application to the board, so build that into the timeline whether the apartment is in Tribeca, the West Village, or Brooklyn Heights.
What closing costs does an estate pay when it sells a NYC home?
The estate is the seller, so it generally pays the seller's transfer taxes. New York City's Real Property Transfer Tax is 1.425 percent on residential sales of more than $500,000. New York State's transfer tax is 0.4 percent, rising to 0.65 percent on residential sales in the city of $3,000,000 or more.
On a $4,000,000 estate sale of a Fort Greene or Cobble Hill townhouse, that is $57,000 in city transfer tax and $26,000 in state transfer tax, or $83,000 combined. Broker commissions, attorney fees, any co-op flip tax, and payoff of any mortgage come on top of that.
Work With The Brewer Team
An estate sale is two processes running side by side: the court and tax calendar on one track, and the property, the building, and the market on the other. The executor's job is to keep both moving without leaving value behind.
The Brewer Team at Compass, led by Sean Brewer and Elina Brewer, brings 30 combined years of experience, more than $400M sold, and 2,500 transactions across Downtown Manhattan and Brooklyn, along with 1,000+ rental units at 95% occupancy. To prepare an inherited property for market, start with our Seller's Guide at BrewerTeamNYC.com.
Frequently Asked Questions
Can an executor sell a house without all the beneficiaries agreeing in New York?
Generally, yes. Once the Surrogate's Court appoints the executor, the executor can usually sell estate real estate without every beneficiary's consent, unless the will prohibits it or the letters restrict the sale. If the letters are restricted, the executor must give notice and ask the court to approve the contract.
How long does an executor have to sell a house in NYC?
New York does not set a single deadline for the sale itself. The practical deadlines come from estate tax returns, due nine months after death, from carrying costs, and in co-ops, from proprietary lease provisions that require a transfer or sale within a set period after the shareholder's death.
Do you pay capital gains tax when selling an inherited home?
Only on gain above the stepped-up basis, which is generally the home's fair market value on the date of death. If the home was worth $4,000,000 at death and sells for $4,100,000, the gain is $100,000 before selling costs, regardless of what the original owner paid.
Is there an estate tax in New York State?
Yes. For deaths in 2026, New York's basic exclusion amount is $7,350,000. If the taxable estate exceeds that amount by more than 5 percent, the entire estate becomes taxable, not just the amount above the threshold.